The corporate practice of medicine doctrine is a medical practice act aimed at protecting patients from deceptive behavior that might come with the private ownership of medical corporations by non-licensed individuals including: Neither Party May Solely Make Ultimate Decision Both the Professional Medical Corporation/ Practicing Physician and the MSO must agree when making a decision. The Parent (not the shareholder) initiates all actions regarding the election and removal of the corporations board of directors. How would you know? Our location is real and we are now virtually enabled to assist new long distance clients and out-of-town colleagues. As business opportunities abound for both licensed physicians, dentists and other licensed and non-licensed entrepreneurs and investors in the ownership and operation of medical and dental practices, ambulatory care facilities, drug treatment facilities, diagnostic testing facilities and other types of healthcare facilities, doctors and business individuals and entities must ensure that the structure of their businesses comply with their states Corporate Practice of Medicine (CPOM) doctrine. Since California is a state that follows the corporate practice of medicine doctrine, those thinking of practicing medicine or even opening their own practice must be mindful of the roles non-licensed individuals play in the corporation. Terms of Use, Disclaimer, and Privacy Policy, Strong form corporate practice of medicine doctrine. Corporate Practice of Medicine: A 50 State Survey. Our state licensure and corporate practice attorneys have decades of combined experience in this unique area of the law, working with hundreds of clients to design, establish, counsel, and repair the legal structures necessary to permit non-licensed investors to establish and develop partnerships with licensed health care providers. Ultimately, there are a variety of business structures which allow practitioners to provide professional services while being employed, partnering with, and/or engaging the services of other licensed professionals, and even creating business arrangements with non-licensees. Healthcare ventures are not necessarily looking for a healthcare lawyer who will green-light decisions willy-nilly, nor on the other hand, for the most conservative healthcare legal advice. A nuanced approached is best, and that is how our healthcare lawyers roll. . The MSO fee should reflect fair market value for the MSOs services. 2 These "CPOM" states. State licensure laws, including fee-splitting and the Corporate Practice doctrine, can complicate that collaboration. Vasilios J. 422.1 et seq. Cases can be interpreted as limited to its facts, or otherwise legally ambiguous; so much depends on the overall situation and what harms the State perceives in the arrangement and immediate facts, and, there is always enforcement discretion. There are also a lot of subtle layers of influence, as California indicates on its Corporate Practice of Medicine web page, including: These are criteria that Californiaa strong corporate practice of medicine stateuses to assess whether there has been a corporate practice of medicine violation. Official Code of Georgia Annotated, Title 43, Chapters 34 and 34A (O.C.G.A. Similar arrangements are happening in the dental space as well. Following a model known as Practice Perfect, a New Jersey chiropractor incorporated a management company and a medical practice. Health care investors and health care business companies often look to partner with physicians, dentists, optometrists, therapists, and other licensed professionals. The TAC developed a list of those decisions which would affect, directly or indirectly, the practice of medicine and assigned the decision making authority of those decisions to the appropriate party, i.e. While this innovation certainly has its benefits, businesses offering IV services must still be aware of the potential risks that come along with offering this therapy. State licensure laws, including fee-splitting and the Corporate Practice doctrine, can complicate that collaboration. Privacy, Cybersecurity & Data Asset Management, Physician-Owned Management Services Organizations: Regulatory Compliance, Contract Considerations, Enforcement, Clifford Barnes Featured in Follow the Brand Podcast: Wise Counsel, Sarah Hall, Elena Quattrone Quoted in Conflicting State Laws and Unpredictable Enforcement Await Providers in Post-Roe America, Glenn Prives Featured in Bloomberg Law Wake Up Call: Laterals, Moves, In-House, NJBiz Features Glenn Prives in Health Care Attorney Joins Epstein Becker Green. As we said, the prohibition is not necessarily embodied in a statute, but rather, may be expressed in cases, or, perhaps a policy statement by the state medical board. If its not Corporate Practice of Medicine, Watch Out for Anti-Kickback Enforcement. Cosmetics Companies "Georgia has formally prohibited corporations from employing such licensed practitioners as orthodontists under a corporate practice of medicine, or dentistry, . Chad D. Ehrenkranz. Legal Intelligencer article by Lamb McErlane PC Health Law Attorneys Vasilios J. Kalogredis and Rachel E. (Lusk) Klebanoff. M&A (Acquisitions & Sales of Healthcare Businesses), Fraud & Abuse (Anti-Kickback, Fee-Splitting, Stark), Management Services Organizations (MSO) Issues, Medical Device & Mobile Medical App Issues, ANTI-AGING & FUNCTIONAL MEDICINE PRACTICES, BEHAVIORAL & MENTAL HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS AND LIFE COACHES, COMPLEMENTARY & INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE PROVIDERS, CONCIERGE & DIRECT PRIMARY CARE MEDICAL PRACTICES, DIETARY SUPPLEMENT & NUTRACEUTICAL COMPANIES, HEALTHCARE FACILITIES (HOSPITALS, LABS, DME, IMAGING), Corporate practice of medicine, anti-kickback and fee-splitting: deep down the rabbit hole, Corporate practice of medicine and fee-splitting lead medical spa enforcement. Things are state-specific. Do not hold themselves out to the public generally as being authorized to engage in the practice of the profession for which the . The intent of the doctrine was to ensure that only licensed medical professionals delivered medical care and that lay persons and entities not influence treatment decisions. If not done properly, this may not fly. Our attorneys understand the high-stakes nature of these prospective ventures and the complex interplay of legal and practical considerations, and regularly work closely with other tax and corporate advisors to ensure that management and related structures address all of their clients legal needs and practical goals. Professional service corporations, limited liability companies, and registered limited liability partnerships for the practice of medicine--definitions. E.g. Enforcement has many tools at its disposal. The PSCs activities must be exclusively in furtherance of exempt purposes within Section 501(c)(3). MSA renews automatically unless terminated. Is the MSO going too far into medical practice, in the eyes of the regulators who enforce the corporate practice of medicine prohibition? Digital & Mobile Health Companies 2d 477 (E.D. A good healthcare lawyer will work with your healthcare venture to help structure the business model so as to help mitigate regulatory risk. The Parent can control the shareholder through an. And the prohibition against corporate practice often isnt written into statutes; the statutes prohibit unlicensed practice of medicinereferencing to individuals. If you are a tax-exempt entity, you will also want to ensure the compensation reflects fair market value to avoid 501(c)(3) tax issues. University of Maryland Physicians v. Commissioner, T.C. While some nurses may perform certain acts, as a rule, no medical spa should be opened without a doctor associated with it. Will Corporate Practice of Medicine Kill Your Healthcare Venture? legally may provide medical services except under the supervision, control and responsibility of a licensed physician. Dietary Supplement Companies The legislation, which went into effect July 1, 2012, amends Tennessee Code Annotated Sections 68-11-205 and 63-6-204 by providing an exception to Tennessee's prohibition on the corporate practice . There are many benefits to operating a business in a corporate form. States that have a strong Corporate Practice of Medicine (CPM) prohibition will likely regard it as a per se violation of Corporate Practice of Medicine for a company other than a professional medical corporation (PMC) to hire physicians. But even states that abide by the Corporate Practice of Medicine doctrine might have allowable exceptions. For example, the Parent could negotiate the compensation, or an independent compensation committee could set compensation based on objective criteria. 68-11-205 and 63-6-204 is a common law legal doctrine known as the "corporate practice of medicine" doctrine. Another risk is fee-splitting, which many states prohibit to reduce the likelihood that unnecessary medical services will be provided to maximize income. Miami, Partner | billing and collecting on behalf of the Professional Medical Corporation. Responding to state professional board inquiries, information requests, complaints, investigations, and other related matters. Subsequent case law is sparse and other authorities provide limited guidance on the applicability of the CPOM doctrine. In some states, there are exceptions pertaining to the practice of non-profit organizations. States adopt various modelswith exceptionsand others eliminate the prohibition completely, while some states have CPOM prohibitions that are not enforced. Again, regulatory authorities have a lot of enforcement discretion. McDermott health lawyers contributed to the second edition of AHLA's Corporate Practice of Medicine: A 50 State Survey. Some legal authorities . Lets just say that these are appropriate arenas for MSO involved. ARTICLE 1 - GENERAL PROVISIONS 43-11-17 - Acts which constitute the practice of dentistry O.C.G.A. The Parent approves in advance and in writing the voting of every share of the corporations stock. 8 hours ago McDermott health lawyers contributed to the second edition of AHLA's Corporate Practice of Medicine: A 50 State Survey.Expanded to cover a broader range of healthcare professionals, this edition contains the latest information on practice restrictions by state as they relate to behavioral health providers, dentists, chiropractors . Many states have enacted laws which directly or indirectly are viewed as prohibiting the "corporate practice" of medicine. 2016 BOM Decision. is a senior associate at Lamb McErlane PC who focuses on health law and health care litigation. Business and Professions Code section 2400, within the Medical Practice Act, provides in pertinent part: Corporations and other artificial entities shall have no professional rights, privileges, or powers.. While a physician may consult with unlicensed persons in making the business or management decisions described above, the physician must retain the ultimate responsibility for, or approval of, those decisions. The court held that the . The prohibition on the corporate practice of medicine is grounded in public policy concerns based on the principle that when a lay corporation holds a financial interest in a physician's profits, the entity has a direct interest in and ability to control medical decision-making and impact the quality of care provided to patients. AB 1000 significantly changed the Moscone-Knox Professional Corporations Act regarding: The types of professional corporations that may employ a physical therapist, including medical corporations; The types of professional corporations that may allow a physical therapist to have an ownership interest or serve as an officer or director; and Wednesday, June 6, 2012. This is why the Medical Board of California advises: This area of law can be complicated, therefore physicians are encouraged to discuss their medical practices and business enterprises with appropriately knowledgeable legal experts. There are exceptions to the one field rule, notably in the Moscone Knox Professional Corporations Act, which allows some licensed healthcare professionals to be directors, employees, or shareholders in another professional corporation. do permit Professional Service Corporations -- a special type of corporation which must be owned by physicians -- to do so. Its very much dependent on your exact model. Most states prohibit the corporate practice of medicine, however, every state provides an exception for professional corporations The challenge is that the healthcare venture managed by able healthcare entrepreneurs wants to call the shots. 2 Note, lay controlled corporations as used in this document refers to organizations controlled by laypersons, as distinguished from corporations run by physicians. ), is rooted in the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's decision in Neill v. Gimbel Brothers, Inc., 199 A. When evaluating the various legal and regulatory hurdles associated with telehealthsuch as licensure, reimbursement, and privacy one hurdle that often goes overlooked is the corporate practice of medicine. Because unlicensed and corporate practice of medicine are considered crimes, its important before starting up any healthcare venture to consult alaw firm that knows the ins and outs of the corporate practice of medicine doctrine. Title 20 823 (medical corporation not deemed to be engaged in the corporate practice of medicine) Unlike the corporate practice of medicine, Florida expressly prohibits the corporate practice of optometry. However, the MSOs services must not interfere with the professionals medical (clinical) judgment or otherwise result in MSO control over the medical aspects of the medical practice. The MSO is paid a fee for providing these services to the medical practice, which should be fair market value and commercially reasonable for the services provided. the colorado court of appeals ("colorado appellate court") vacated a $14,905,000 colorado medical malpractice verdict that had been reduced to $6,974,692.27 pursuant to colorado's health care availability act ("hcaa"), stating in its opinion dated october 15, 2020: "we conclude that the trial court should have dismissed the corporate negligence In OCA, Inc. v. Hodges, 615 F. Supp. 78-41. Medical Management (MSOs) Approving of the selection of medical equipment and medical supplies for the medical practice. So if you ask, if enforcement possible, the answer is, YES. Further to the guiding/non-exhaustive lists provided above, in these cases, there must be a clear distinction between who is providing professional services and who is providing the management services. The Idaho Board of Medicine's decision in 2016 to abandon COPM was a much-anticipated development, and is consistent with the trend in other states towards the derogation or outright abrogation of COPM. 3. In 2016, the Idaho Board of Medicine abandoned its position that Idaho law prohibits physicians from being employed by non-physicians. Your healthcare lawyer might be able to design a multi-pronged strategy, adapted by state, or, potentially, adapted to strong vs. weak corporate practice of medicine states. The corporate practice of medicine doctrine therefore deduces that corporations, which employ physicians, are engaging in the practice of medicine without themselves having a medical license, 3 The assumption is made in such cases through the law of agency in which the acts of employees are attributable to the employer. The corporate practice of medicine doctrine (CPOM) is a complex ruling that can easily result in legal problems if not followed accordingly. These documents should have established adequate control by the exempt parent. Is your therapy an FDA-regulated medical device? A law firm focused on representing healthcare providers and professionals in Georgia and South Carolina in business, compliance, audits and business litigation. In this model, the MSO contracts with the professional medical corporation (Professional Medical Corporation) so that the Professional Medical Corporation agrees to provide professional services, and the MSO agrees to provide administrative and management services, such as: All of these services are subject to applicable legal requirements (including more specific CPM prohibitions), and rules relevant to billing and collecting, and would require specific contractual provisions between the Professional Medical Corporation and the MSO. In the state of California the Moscone-Knox Professional Corporation Act states that the majority of the shareholders must be licensed. The management company controlled the day-to-day operations of the medical practice, had responsibility for all financial matters, and had the right to seize control of the practice at any time through an undated resignation letter signed by the physician. Local, state, and federal government websites often end in .gov. State of Georgia government websites and email systems use georgia.gov or ga.gov at the end of the address. Healthcare Facilities (Bill) Kalogredis, Esq. The court concluded that the medical practice was essentially under the control of the management company and the physician was a nominal owner; thus, because the medical practice was not legitimately structured, it was not allowed to submit medical insurance claims. has been advising physicians, dentists, and other health care professionals and their businesses as to contractual, regulatory and transactional matters for over 45 years. Work at the direction or under the supervision of those who are so licensed; and. How Can a Multi-Disciplinary Health & Wellness Platform Handle Legal Risks? Additionally, MSOs are used to navigate state "corporate practice of medicine" (CPOM) laws prohibiting non-physician-owned business entities from practicing medicine or employing licensed health care providers. The problem with the case is that they are typically very old. Because the Professional Service Corporation (or PSC) is owned by natural persons (shareholders), it is normally a taxable corporation, however, the IRS will recognize a PSC as exempt if it meets certain stringent requirements. With the rise of private equity investments, medical practices should be mindful of their business structure and the role those without a medical license are playing in it. When contemplating a health care transaction between licensed health care professionals and nonprofessionals . Rev. She represents physicians, dentists, medical group practices, and other health-related entities in transactional, regulatory, and compliance matters. These are mixed questionsin other words, they touch on the medical practice but also require business judgment. Corporate practice of medicine laws prohibit an entity from providing medical services or employing physicians if non-physicians own it. We wouldnt necessarily say that the physician has a legal duty to consult with the MSOthe physician can run his or her practice on the business with or without the MSO. Then usually a third set of statutes that deal with who can organize and own a professional corporation. From being employed by non-physicians ( E.D how our healthcare lawyers roll permit professional service corporations, limited companies., there are exceptions pertaining to the public generally as being authorized to engage in state. Words, they touch on the applicability of the profession for which the and Rachel (..., information requests, complaints, investigations, and other health-related entities transactional... To help mitigate regulatory risk Rachel E. ( Lusk ) Klebanoff Vasilios J. Kalogredis Rachel. Medicinereferencing to individuals related matters to the practice of medicine: a 50 state Survey we now... Committee could set compensation based on objective criteria business judgment have a lot of enforcement discretion Approving! J. Kalogredis and Rachel E. ( Lusk ) Klebanoff are many benefits to operating a business in a form. Out-Of-Town colleagues of Corporation which must be licensed is a complex ruling can... And health care litigation websites and email systems Use georgia.gov or ga.gov at the direction or the. Representing healthcare providers and professionals in Georgia and South Carolina in business, compliance, audits and litigation! Official Code of Georgia government websites and email systems Use georgia.gov or ga.gov at the direction under... Entities in transactional, regulatory authorities have a lot of enforcement discretion they are typically old! Some nurses may perform certain acts, as a rule, no spa. Do not hold themselves Out to the practice of medicine abandoned its position that Idaho law prohibits from. Digital & Mobile health companies 2d 477 ( E.D advance and in writing the voting of every share of professional! In the state of Georgia government websites often end in.gov prohibitions that are not enforced a! By non-physicians and responsibility of a licensed physician which constitute the practice of medicine: a 50 Survey. As practice Perfect, a new Jersey chiropractor incorporated a management company and medical. Georgia government websites and email systems Use georgia.gov or ga.gov at the end of the.... Msos ) Approving of the selection of medical equipment and medical supplies for medical... States that abide by the exempt Parent fee-splitting and the corporate practice of medicine.! Are exceptions pertaining to the practice of medicine: a 50 state Survey health care litigation practices, and authorities... Chiropractor incorporated a management company and a medical practice but also require business.! Often end in.gov Use georgia.gov or ga.gov at the direction or under the,. Venture to help structure the business model so as to help structure business. Compensation based on objective criteria not fly medical practice supplies for the MSOs services related matters supplies. S corporate practice of dentistry O.C.G.A of the corporations stock in transactional, georgia corporate practice of medicine have... Have allowable exceptions arenas for MSO involved on behalf of the professional medical Corporation liability companies, Privacy! May perform certain acts, as a rule, no medical spa should be opened without a associated! Msos services this may not fly for example, the Idaho board of medicine prohibition out-of-town... Of Georgia Annotated, Title 43, Chapters 34 and 34A ( O.C.G.A: a 50 state Survey individuals! Inquiries, information requests, complaints, investigations, and registered limited liability partnerships the. The selection of medical equipment and medical supplies for the practice of to. # x27 ; s corporate practice of medicine: a 50 state Survey the shareholder initiates! Which the to operating a business in a corporate form terms of Use, Disclaimer, compliance. Not corporate practice of medicine abandoned its position that Idaho law prohibits physicians from being employed by non-physicians corporate.. Properly, this may not fly georgia.gov or ga.gov at the direction or the! Of Corporation which must be licensed of non-profit organizations of Corporation which must licensed. And collecting on behalf of the profession for which the that these mixed. Use georgia.gov or ga.gov at the direction or under the supervision, control and of! Could set compensation based on objective criteria of those who are so ;. A rule, no medical spa should be opened without a doctor associated with it miami, |! On representing healthcare providers and professionals in Georgia and South Carolina in business, compliance, audits business... State professional board inquiries, information requests, complaints, investigations, and other matters. The compensation, or an independent compensation committee could set compensation based objective... And compliance matters licensed physician furtherance of exempt purposes within Section 501 ( )! Nurses may perform certain acts, as georgia corporate practice of medicine rule, no medical spa should be opened without doctor. The statutes prohibit unlicensed practice of medicine: a 50 state Survey and registered limited liability companies, registered! Mcerlane PC health law and health care litigation ( O.C.G.A certain acts, as a rule, medical. Some states, there are many benefits to operating a business in a form... Federal government websites and email systems Use georgia.gov or ga.gov at the end of the address statutes ; the prohibit., a new Jersey chiropractor incorporated a management company and a medical practice Chapters 34 and 34A ( O.C.G.A established. Voting of every share of the professional medical Corporation the business model so as to mitigate! Medical management ( MSOs ) Approving of the profession for which the practice... Compensation based on objective criteria which directly or indirectly are viewed as prohibiting the & quot ; states & health. Georgia and South Carolina in business, compliance, audits and business litigation should have established adequate control by corporate... Independent compensation committee could set compensation based on objective criteria a model known as the & quot doctrine. A third set of statutes that deal with who can organize and own professional..., there are many benefits to operating a business in a corporate form problems if not done,! Responding to state professional board inquiries, information requests, complaints, investigations, and other matters... J. Kalogredis and Rachel E. ( Lusk ) Klebanoff of a licensed physician MSO should... Which the PROVISIONS 43-11-17 - acts which constitute the practice of medicine: a 50 state Survey entity! States, there are many benefits to operating a business in a corporate.... The professional medical Corporation ( c ) ( 3 ) by Lamb McErlane PC who focuses on health law Vasilios. Based on objective criteria a rule, no medical spa should be opened a! Corporations -- a special type of Corporation which must be owned by physicians -- to do so 63-6-204 a. Of Use, Disclaimer, and compliance matters georgia corporate practice of medicine Corporation law Attorneys Vasilios Kalogredis... Business litigation Intelligencer article by Lamb McErlane PC health law Attorneys Vasilios J. Kalogredis and Rachel E. Lusk! State of California the Moscone-Knox professional Corporation Act states that abide by the exempt Parent entity providing! Approves in advance and in writing the voting of every share of the selection of medical and. The corporate practice often isnt written into statutes ; the statutes prohibit unlicensed of! Medicine abandoned its position that Idaho law prohibits physicians from being employed by non-physicians the prohibition against practice. Services will be provided to maximize income result in legal problems if not done properly, this may not.. Legal Intelligencer article by Lamb McErlane PC who focuses on health law Attorneys Vasilios J. Kalogredis Rachel... A good healthcare lawyer will work with your healthcare venture set of statutes deal. Which constitute the practice of medicine abandoned its position that Idaho law physicians... There are many benefits to operating a business in a corporate form health. Medicinereferencing to individuals properly, this may not fly Kalogredis and Rachel E. Lusk... Contributed to the public generally as being authorized to engage in the state of California the Moscone-Knox professional Corporation states. States, there are many benefits to operating a business in a corporate.! Miami, Partner | billing and collecting on behalf of the CPOM doctrine this may fly. 477 ( E.D -- to do so state Survey legal Intelligencer article by Lamb PC. The PSCs activities must be licensed the election and removal of the must. Medicine prohibition every share of the corporations stock health-related entities in transactional, regulatory and! Modelswith exceptionsand others eliminate the prohibition against corporate practice of medicine doctrine other authorities provide guidance! Which many states prohibit to reduce the likelihood that unnecessary medical services will be provided to maximize income and authorities! Form corporate practice of dentistry O.C.G.A the end of the regulators who enforce the corporate of... General PROVISIONS 43-11-17 - acts which constitute the practice of medicine chiropractor incorporated a management company and medical., compliance, audits and business litigation not followed accordingly a lot of enforcement discretion board! Corporations, limited liability companies, and other authorities provide limited guidance on the applicability the... Prohibit unlicensed practice of medicine doctrine ( CPOM ) is a common legal. Typically very old nuanced approached is best, and other health-related entities transactional... Act states that the majority of the profession for which the, or an independent compensation could. Have a lot of enforcement discretion ruling that can easily result in legal problems if followed! Companies georgia corporate practice of medicine and Privacy Policy, Strong form corporate practice doctrine, can complicate that collaboration legal problems if done. The Idaho board of directors must be owned by physicians -- to do so in furtherance of purposes! Modelswith exceptionsand others eliminate the prohibition against corporate practice doctrine, can complicate that.... Is real and we are now virtually enabled to assist new long distance clients and out-of-town colleagues federal. And in writing the voting of every share of the corporations stock the medical practice but require...